The thing about The Ferryman is that he’s a man of influence who, due to tragic circumstances, gains an ability that, as we’ll learn as the saga of the Legion continues, is going to drive him a little nuts. Besieged by the spirits of the newly murdered, he is driven to avenge them and silence the howling in his head. So we’d need somebody who’s classy but a little off, as if something will snap at any time.
Now last time I gave you a retro casting as well as a modern one. If I had somehow gone back in time and somehow convinced a studio to make a SL movie, I would have ideally wanted Martin Landau to don the cloak and crimson blindfold for it. There’s an intensity to Landau that I think will translate well to the Ferryman’s visage.
Now onto the here and now....
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0cdf7/0cdf7deba09ec5f6e48689ae6e4b2d1c45a4a38c" alt=""
the way Murphy is good looking but...off. A lot of it is, of course, those far away eyes of his that always make me think he’s plotting something unsavory. More importantly, we’ve seen him play sober and serious as well as massively deranged--in the case of Batman Begins, in the very same movie! I can easily see him slowly transitioning from urbane socialite to tortured avenger over the course of a movie until the point where he’s actively scary.
Incidentally, given that my first two casting choices were in their late 30‘s, I’m thinking I may have to adjust my requirements upwards so everyone can appear to be, well, peers.
Do you agree? Disagree? Have another idea? Let me know.